Nicholson Builders

Nancy Sherman

2023-05

We have had quite a few projects performed by Nicholson Builders over the past couple of years, including the total rebuild of our brick front porch, the addition of a wooden ceiling in our foyer, a shower remodel with new tile, the addition of moulding on our stairway walls and the installation of a stainless-steel shelf on our rear deck. And we have several other future projects that we are planning to complete with Nicholson Builders. None of these projects are inexpensive nowadays, but knowing that a truly courteous, professional and experienced team is doing the work gives you tremendous peace of mind. This is the type of experience you will always receive from Nicholson Builders. From their office staff to their project managers to their technicians, you will never find a better group people to deal with. We love Nicholson Builders!Services: Tile work installation, Bathroom remodeling, Remodeling, Plumbing fixture installation, Fan repair

Karen Kuns

2024-03

Nicholson Builders exceeded our expectations! Working with the small projects division was so easy. They tackled a handful of home upgrades and some smaller fixes, too. Everyone who worked on our project was friendly and professional. I won't let those home projects pile up now that I know I can trust Nicholson Builders to complete them quickly and efficiently. Thank you for helping us with these improvements!

Sam Peterson

2024-01

We recently worked the Nicholson's small project division and had a GREAT experience. We had a ton of small deferred maintenance projects around the house and didn't know what to do about them. We had tried to hire handymen in the past, but never had a good experience. So a lot of things just lingered because we didn't know what to do, or who to call to fix them.We finally called Nicholson because we had friends who raved about the work they did for a larger home remodeling project. Our hope was that their small projects division would be able to help fix up things around our house.They delivered and then some! We had a fantastic experience working with them. Every single person we interacted with was professional, thoughtful, and incredibly helpful. There was great communication from start to finish, they worked with our schedule and were able to accommodate other projects we were doing around the house and, of course, the workmanship was top notch.We'll absolutely hire them again for any project; I have complete trust in them and their work. I've already recommended them to several friends for projects large and small.

Faith Durand

2024-02

Nicholson's Small Projects division has completed two projects at our home over the past few years, and we could not be more thrilled with the results. The team communicates well, does gorgeous work, and always is so unfailingly pleasant and thoughtful. They are always our first pick for a job that needs attention to detail and good craftsmanship.

Adeeti Chiplunker

2024-03

I am particular about construction projects and Nicholson’s expertise and experience is top notch. I utilized their small projects division and they treated it as if were a much larger project. Not once did I feel like my project was less important even though it was smaller. From start to finish, Bryan, Paul and especially Josiah were exceptional. I will absolutely be asking them to handle more projects around my house!

Denise Bronson

2024-04

Nicholson Builders replaced the decking on our front porch. We were extremely happy with all aspects of this project — from the initial contact with Nicholson to the completion of the project. We dealt with several people who assessed the issues with the porch and advised us on how to proceed. Ultimately, the project was assigned to the small projects division and, partly due to the unseasonably warm weather, was completed quickly. The finished porch looks great, and we were very appreciative of the attention to detail given to this work.Shortly after finishing the porch project, we discovered that our bathroom shower had developed a leak; we immediately contacted Nicholson again. They came out quickly to assess the problem and a short time later began the repairs. The repairs presented some unexpected challenges but we were impressed with the efforts to solve the problems and the extent to which we were included in the decision-making. Once again, we were extremely happy with the results, the process, and the crew. Thank you Bryan, Nick, Jack, and Al.

Barbara Yehsakul

2024-02

We have used Nicholson for a small project and a large bathroom remodel. You will have to be on a waitlist but it is worth it. They are comprehensive and their work is impeccable. The design team was a fountain of ideas and I felt free to express my likes and my dislikes. They took all questions and concerns seriously and I knew that they were there to make sure I was happy with every choice along with way. There are always unexpected things that arise in a reno but they handled each one deftly. Their workers are clean and courteous and very respectful of my time and home. Their communication was excellent I always knew what to expect. I hope that the renovation stage of our home is over but if not...they will be my first phone call.

Karen Gartner

2023-12

I had a morning consultation scheduled with Nicholson Builders, and spoke to the consultant right before he was due to come, clarifying that I needed advice from someone with marble/tile experience for problems that we are having with our shower. Bryan had me send pictures of my marble shower, and then used those pictures to get some expert advice from his contacts. It ended up that he consulted with me over the phone vs coming out, and saved me the consulting fee. (He said not to worry about it.) I was very impressed with Bryan's efforts (and time--several phone calls) to help me, and now I have a much better idea of what course of action to take. I am thankful for the ethic of helpfulness, for possible future business.

Terri Petty

2024-02

I have asked Nicholson Builders to do several projects for us. From creating new front steps to handrails in the house as well as metal handrails I can’t say enough about how professional they are as well as knowledgeable and they always cleanup at the end of their work. I would highly recommend.

Jim Manning

2020-05

Nicholson renovated our kitchen last year and did an excellent job. They were really everything we could have asked for in a contractor. They offered the full range of services we needed, from consulting on the design to the many skills needed to complete the job with high quality. They communicated the schedule very clearly and delivered on time, all the while being cognizant and respectful of the fact that we were living in the house at the time.

Marty Hibbard

2023-09

Our first experience with Nicholson Builders was very positive. Their workers are very talented and professional. They cleaned up every day and made sure that we were satisfied with the work. They offered helpful suggestions for us to consider as well. We definitely will consider using them again for future projects.

Clint Burgess

2024-01

Working with Nicholson Builders you have professionals that are dedicated to you, in turning what is on the plans into a stunning reality.One of the top builders in Columbus...I would highly recommend to anyone.

Nick Keplar

2023-09

I have worked with Nicholson Builders for a couple of years now. This company provides the upmost professional and quality services that the remodeling industry has to offer. If you are looking to invest in your home and create a truly unique space that is created by the best craftsman the industry has to offer, then look no further. From the initial estimate all the way to the finish line, this company is the best. Hands down!

Alan Davis

2024-02

We had a structural issue that could only be diagnosed by removing siding and looking. PM Bryan Copley of the Small Projects Division sent a good team, led by Alfred, who examined the problem then consulted with their in-house architect that came up with a solution that was less expense than expected. They did a great job with the repair and the team members were courteous and competent.

Grace Taylor

2023-08

I am a long time customer of Nicholson Builders. They have done small and large projects for two of my homes. Their staff have great craftsman skills along with being punctual, professional & polite. My home was always left clean & orderly at the end of the day. I highly recommend Nicolson Builders and will continue to use them for my home projects!

Josh Watts

2023-05

My wife and I are very pleased with our decision to partner with Nicholson Builders. We had a small but complex extension to our house. Everyone from design to construction to finishes were great to work with. They were a very professional, knowledgeable and attentive group. It was a long process, and they made a difficult situation to live through as painless as possible. I look forward to working with them again.Service: Remodeling

Jeff Grunewald

2024-02

We were super pleased with the addition they renovated onto our family room. Everyone from the design team to the awesome contractors were super attentive to detail, accommodating and very nice to work with. Will hire again!

Cindy Walter

2023-05

Nicholson Builders just finished our kitchen remodel project. It couldn't have turned out better. We did the design ourselves using IKEA cabinets. Nicholson did the complete installation including cabinets, countertops, appliances, patching the ceiling (matched the ceiling pattern perfectly), new flooring. The quality is excellent. Wayne was our project lead. He kept us informed throughout the project. We were out of town for most of the work. He had video chats with us and sent texts and photos whenever there were decisions to be made. The project was done on time, and within budget.Service: Remodeling

M A

2023-11

I have not done business with these guys but I want to share my short experience with them in case someone else is interested. I had an interior door installation project which should cost roughly $1000 or so, I thought their small project department would be a good fit. I sent a message over their website and after 10 days of waiting, they told me to re-send the message this time via email. I thought whatever and sent the message only to hear that they ask for $100 just to come and take a look... They say this protects their consultants' time... Cool... What about my time wasted waiting for response. I have had so many remodelling projects over the years and these are the only guys who ask for money upfront... Also they did not say anything about using the money towards the project cost, if I agree on pursuing with the business. As I said, I just did not like their work style, lack of communication and passion to make easy money... If you are ok with those, go ahead and give it a try. I have not paid a dime for someone to take a look at the site not even for projects that cost over $10k and never will do.

Ashley Sklenicka

2023-10

In our new to us home we had small projects that needed done and their team delivered. My Grandmother's motto of "touch it once," when doing a project is a great way to sum up their wonderful work. Electrical, drywall patching, and internet cable running were up on our list first and they exceeded all expectations. So much so, we are already scheduled to have them come look at a few more items on our list. If you're looking for hands-on service done right the first time, with care toward the customer, then you've found the right company.

Alexis Hansen

2020-05

We've worked with Nicholson Builders on large and small projects throughout our 1893 Victorian home. Our most recent project was a house addition and full kitchen renovation which also included relocating a powder room. From planning and designing until completion, the Nicholson team takes excellent care of us. They really listen to our needs, including our more creative requests, and they are willing to work out all the little details that make a huge difference in the functionality and aesthetics of a space. If there are any problems along the way, Nicholson are quick and considerate in addressing them. They work cleanly, carefully and are very thorough. The quality of their construction and craftsmanship is exceptional. They respect a historic home and employ creative and appropriate solutions to issues unique to older homes. We will definitely work with Nicholson on future home projects. Our experience with them is unequivocally positive in every respect.

Charlie Baldwin

2021-05

We highly recommend Nicholson Builders. Their talented and personable people made our kitchen renovation a pleasant experience from start to finish. They listened to what we wanted and came up with additional ideas to further enhance the kitchen's function. They provided a perfect balance between letting us make choices and guiding us when we needed help. The workmanship was top-notch and the project moved along in a very timely manner. We always felt that our satisfaction was important to them. As time goes by we are appreciating, even more, the special nuances in design and craftsmanship. We got a wonderfully functional kitchen wrapped up in a beautiful package. Kudos to our team of Jeremy, Amy and Chuck!Service: Remodeling

Phil Glandon

2021-05

We have used Nicholson Builders for a number of projects including a complete remodel of the first floor of our home, a new master bathroom, a porch addition, and as small as a basement egress window. Every project has exceeded our expectations. Their team members are all professional and fun to have around. We actually miss them when our projects are completed. On the rare occasion when something didn't meet our expectations, they fixed it immediately with no questions asked. We can't say enough about what a great organization Nicholson Builders is to do business with!Service: Remodeling

Lynn Inskeep

2020-05

I have worked with Nicholson Builders as a trade partner for over 15 years. They are one of my favorite teams to work with. They truly become part of your family, and I have met and worked with many of their clients on multiple projects over the years. They listen to you, they are innovative, imaginative and incredible people. You can trust that they will take care of all of your needs, work to say in your budget, and get the job done!

Peter Accetta

2020-05

I have used Nicholson Builders for a number of projects at my home including roofing, bathroom remodeling, deck refurbishing, wood trim repair and others. They are simply exceptional from a workmanship point of view and reliability. Also, they are very fair in terms of their change order costs, and their bids are right in line with the final costs. The workers are friendly, always on time, and they keep the job sites very clean. All of the projects have been completed ON TIME, if not sooner. 5 stars all the way.

Jan Gasser

2020-05

We had used Nicholson Builders several times at our old house. They were always so pleasant, dependable and trustworthy.So, when we bought an older home to renovate in Worthington Proper they were immediately the ones we thought of to help use. Because of what we wanted in the house and because it was a 1951 Cinder Block house we ended up tearing it down and building.Have never regretted using Nicholson. They have amazing Superviors and Finish Carpenters that are not only talented but problem solvers.We are very pleased with our home and the job / workmanship that Nicholson Builders put into our home to make it special.Jan and Mike Gasser

Jim Nicholson

2020-05

Over the past sixteen years my wife and I have worked on five projects with Nicholson Builders. These ranged from replacing 140 year old flooring in our home, remodeling a craft/sewing room, engineering and installing an electric winch in our attic to raise/lower a large chandelier in an eighteen foot high atrium, rebuilding a cedar fence enclosing our backyard and building an articulated mail drop for our garage door. It's a compliment to Nicholson Builders that the same managers and carpenters we worked with in the beginning are still with the company. Their work is exemplary and we'll continue to work with Nicholson Builders as needed.

kristen Koehn

2021-05

I have not uploaded my photos yet but I would recommend Nicholson Builders to any commercial company or residential looking to remodel or build. We sought them out for a large office remodel including a new kitchen/breakroom design, paint, electric and plumbing as well as adding to our fire system to meet city regulations. They were a pleasure to work with, never giving kickback when a change order was requested and remained flexible with our timeline. 100% met our remodel expectations and more because of their caring attitude, quick responses and flexibility.Services: TV mounting, Paint indoors, Repair water fixtures, Remodeling

Kim Maupin

2023-05

I come from a family of 3 generations of contractors. Nicholson jobs are the most top notch quality projects I have ever seen. Attention to detail is like no other. Communication and customer service is excellent.

M Ahern

2020-05

Nicholson builders is highly ethical and a prime example of true craftsmanship through partnering with their clients. We have used them on multiple projects and have never been disappointed. They do have a longer lead time than other remodelers and they are more expensive than average, but you absolutely get what you pay for. Bill Nicholson and his company are a true gem in the home remodeling field.